RT “We Were on Different Planets”: Carrie Underwood Opens Up About the Fight That Nearly Broke Her Marriage — and the Faith That Saved It
In a rare, deeply personal reflection, Carrie Underwood has opened up about a painful chapter in her marriage — a fight that almost ended everything.
For years, the country superstar and her husband, former NHL player Mike Fisher, have been seen as one of Nashville’s strongest couples. But behind the smiles and success, they faced a moment that nearly tore them apart.
“We were on different planets,” Carrie admitted quietly. “It felt like we weren’t hearing each other anymore.”
The Breaking Point
Discover more
Art
Music
New York
Blue Note
art
Portable speakers
musical
Murals
NYC
Online art courses
The tension came during a time when everything around them seemed perfect — on the outside.
It was 2020, a year when the world slowed down, and so did their carefully balanced routine. For the first time, Carrie wasn’t touring, and Mike wasn’t traveling for hockey. They were home together, with two young boys — and no space to hide from the silence.
“We love each other, of course,” she said. “But love doesn’t mean you always understand. Sometimes it means you’re forced to face what you’ve been ignoring.”
In their Mike and Carrie: God & Country docuseries, both admitted that quarantine magnified their differences. Carrie thrived in structure and stillness, while Mike, a retired athlete used to adrenaline, struggled with the slowdown.
They argued about everything — schedules, parenting styles, even the smallest things like who should do bedtime.
“We weren’t fighting over big issues,” Carrie explained. “It was the little things that build walls if you’re not careful.”
“I Thought Maybe This Was It”
Carrie says there was one night that hit harder than the rest — a moment when she sat alone in their living room, wondering if love was enough.
“I remember thinking, maybe this is it. Maybe we’re just too different,” she said. “I was angry, I was hurt, and I felt like we were losing what made us us.”
Mike, in his own interviews, has called that time “a spiritual test.”
“We didn’t see eye to eye,” he said. “But walking away was never an option — not for us.”
That night, instead of slamming doors or sleeping in separate rooms, Carrie did something unexpected: she prayed.
“I told God, ‘I can’t fix this. If it’s meant to be saved, show me how.’”
It was a moment of surrender — one that changed everything.
The Faith That Pulled Them Back
The next morning, she says, something shifted. They sat down with coffee, and for the first time in weeks, they listened — really listened.
“It wasn’t a magic fix,” Carrie admitted. “But it was the beginning of grace.”
They started praying together daily, something they hadn’t done since early in their marriage. The fights didn’t vanish overnight, but the walls slowly came down.
Mike later told Faithwire,
“We realized we weren’t fighting each other — we were fighting for the same thing. We just forgot to see it that way.”
Since then, Carrie has spoken more openly about how faith became their anchor.
“You learn that love isn’t about being right,” she said. “It’s about choosing each other, even when it’s hard.”
A Marriage Built on Real, Not Perfect
Carrie and Mike celebrated their 15th anniversary this year, and fans continue to admire their honesty — especially now that they’re more open about the struggles that shaped them.
“People see pictures and think it’s perfect,” Carrie said. “But perfect isn’t real. What’s real is working through the mess — and still choosing love at the end of the day.”
She credits that painful chapter for strengthening their relationship, both as partners and as parents.
“Our boys saw us disagree,” she said. “But they also saw us forgive. That’s something I hope they carry with them forever.”
Today, the couple seems stronger than ever — their bond forged not by flawless moments, but by faith, forgiveness, and a lot of patience.
The Bigger Picture
Carrie says she decided to speak about that time not to fuel gossip, but to give hope.
“Every marriage has its breaking point,” she said. “But sometimes the breaking is what makes you stronger. You just have to decide whether you’ll let it break you apart — or build you back together.”
Her words resonated deeply with fans, especially those who’ve followed her journey since her American Idol days. Many commented that they’d rather see their favorite singer “real than perfect.”
“We don’t need to be anyone else’s version of happy,” Carrie said. “We just need to be faithful — to each other, to ourselves, and to God.”
And with that, she smiled, quietly — the kind of smile that comes only after walking through the storm and finding peace on the other side.
