RT “He Said He Wanted To Propose To Me All Over Again”: Carrie Underwood Breaks Down As Mike Fisher Recreates Their Proposal — Just Moments After She Revealed Baby Is On The Way!
It started as a quiet family night — no stage lights, no red carpets, just Carrie Underwood, her husband Mike Fisher, and a handful of close friends gathered at their Tennessee home. But by the end of the evening, tears were flowing, hearts were full, and one of country music’s most beloved couples had written yet another unforgettable chapter in their love story.
Family games
A Double Surprise Nobody Saw Coming
The night began with a toast. Carrie, glowing with that unmistakable warmth that fans have loved for nearly two decades, had gathered everyone together for what she called “a small family announcement.” With her two sons, Isaiah and Jacob, sitting nearby, she smiled shyly and said the words that changed everything:
Discover more
Entertainment center
Gospel music
Portable speakers
Family games
Video
Television
Gift baskets
Home page
AT&T Stadium
Supreme Court of the United States
“We’re having another baby.”
The room erupted in cheers, laughter, and applause. Friends hugged. The boys clapped in confusion before running to hug their mom. Carrie, visibly emotional, wiped away a tear. But while the world was just finding out about her pregnancy, her husband Mike Fisher — the former NHL star who’s always been known for his quiet strength — had a secret of his own.
“He Just Looked at Me… And I Knew Something Was Up”
Moments after the excitement settled, Carrie noticed Mike walking away from the crowd. He turned off the lights, leaving the room illuminated only by dozens of flickering candles arranged in a circle. Then, he reached into his pocket.
At first, Carrie thought he was joking. “I laughed and said, ‘What are you doing?’” she later told People. “But then I saw the look in his eyes — and I realized he wasn’t joking at all.”
Mike Fisher, her husband of nearly 15 years, knelt down on one knee — again — holding a small velvet box.
“He said he wanted to propose to me all over again,” Carrie shared, her voice trembling. “Because this new chapter — this new baby — felt like falling in love all over again.”
Those words were enough to melt even the coldest heart.
A Love Story That Never Stops Growing
Carrie Underwood and Mike Fisher’s love story has long been one of Nashville’s favorites. They first met in 2008, introduced by Carrie’s bassist after a concert. It was love at first sight, though both admit they didn’t expect it to move so fast.
By December 2009, Mike proposed during a snowy evening at Carrie’s parents’ home in Ottawa, Canada. The two tied the knot in July 2010 in a stunning Georgia ceremony surrounded by family, friends, and a who’s who of country music.
Family games
Over the years, they’ve weathered storms — career pressures, time apart, miscarriages, and even public scrutiny — but through it all, they’ve remained anchored in faith and love.
Carrie once said, “Love isn’t perfect. But when it’s real, it never stops choosing you — every single day.”
So when Mike Fisher dropped to one knee again that evening, it wasn’t just romantic. It was symbolic. A promise renewed — not because time had faded their love, but because it had deepened it.
The Proposal 2.0: Every Detail Recreated
What made the moment even more powerful was how thoughtfully Mike recreated their original proposal.
Back in 2009, he’d proposed to Carrie in front of the Christmas tree, surrounded by twinkling lights. This time, he recreated that same magic — only now, instead of Christmas decorations, the room was filled with framed photos of their family through the years: wedding pictures, baby photos, concert snapshots, and one newly taken sonogram print taped to the wall.
“He even played the same song he played that night — ‘Look After You’ by The Fray,” Carrie revealed, tearing up. “I just broke down. I couldn’t believe he remembered every detail.”
After she said “yes” — again — the room burst into applause. Carrie laughed through tears as their boys joined in, with Isaiah exclaiming, “Mommy, are you getting married again?”
Carrie smiled and hugged him close. “No, sweetheart,” she whispered. “Daddy’s just reminding me how much he loves me.”
Social Media Explodes: “The Most Beautiful Thing We’ve Ever Seen”
Though the gathering was private, a close friend captured part of the proposal on video — and with Carrie’s blessing, a short clip was shared on social media the next morning.
The internet immediately lost its mind. Within hours, the hashtag #CarrieAndMikeForever was trending worldwide. Fans flooded the comments with messages like “This is what real love looks like” and “Mike Fisher just set the new standard for every husband in America.”
Country artists from across Nashville chimed in as well. Kelsea Ballerini commented, “I’m crying at 8 a.m. — thank you for reminding us love can still be this pure.” Luke Bryan added a string of heart emojis and wrote, “That’s the kind of man every woman deserves.”
Even Blake Shelton tweeted: “Mike Fisher just made the rest of us look bad. But I’ll allow it — that’s beautiful.”
A New Beginning — For Their Family and Their Hearts
For Carrie, the moment wasn’t about grand gestures — it was about gratitude. After years of highs and heartbreaks, she called this season of her life “a blessing wrapped in grace.”
Family games
“After everything we’ve been through — from losing babies to learning how to be stronger together — this felt like God saying, ‘Here’s your rainbow after the storm.’”
She described how, in recent years, her perspective on love, fame, and family has shifted. “When you’re young, love feels like fireworks,” she said. “Now it feels like a sunrise — quiet, steady, and new every morning.”
The couple’s faith remains the heartbeat of their relationship. Mike, who often shares Bible verses online, wrote a heartfelt post following the proposal, saying:
“Fifteen years later, and I still fall more in love every day. God has blessed me beyond measure with this woman, this family, and now another precious gift on the way. Carrie, I’d choose you every time.”
The World Waits for Baby Number Three
Since the news broke, fans have been speculating about the baby’s gender — though Carrie says even she doesn’t know yet. “We’re waiting to be surprised,” she laughed. “After everything, I think that’s the sweetest gift we can give ourselves.”
Gift baskets
Her upcoming tour dates are reportedly being rescheduled to allow for more family time in the months ahead, and sources close to the couple say Carrie plans to document parts of her pregnancy journey for a potential behind-the-scenes feature later this year.
“Family has always come first,” said a longtime friend. “This baby, and that proposal, reminded her that the greatest stage she’ll ever stand on is home.”
“It Felt Like Starting Over — But Better”
Carrie later shared one final reflection that left fans everywhere misty-eyed:
“He didn’t need to propose again. But he did — not because he had to, but because he wanted to remind me that love isn’t a moment you capture once. It’s something you keep choosing, over and over.”
As she spoke, her voice cracked — but her smile said it all.
The country superstar who has sung about heartbreak, faith, and redemption for nearly two decades just lived out her most moving ballad yet — one written not for the charts, but for the heart.
And as fans across the world celebrate the news of her growing family and rekindled love, Carrie’s words echo softly, like a lyric that will never fade:
“He said he wanted to propose to me all over again — and I said yes, all over again.”
A love story reborn. A family growing. A reminder that even after years of fame, fortune, and life’s hardest battles, the greatest moments still happen in the quiet glow of home — where love kneels, faith rises, and forever begins again.
